Sugar, sweeteners and sugar-free with type 2 diabetes
Sugar, honey and syrup in figures, what "no added sugar" means, and what Mattilsynet, Helsedirektoratet, NHI and Diabetesforbundet say about sweeteners.
General information, not medical advice. Make changes to diet, activity and medication together with your doctor. Read more. Translated from the Norwegian original. Sources are Norwegian pages. Rules and rates apply to Norway.
Short answer
Sugar, honey, syrup and agave syrup give roughly the same rise in blood sugar per gram, however “natural” the product is. “No added sugar” does not mean no sugar. Intense sweeteners such as aspartame, sucralose and stevia do not raise blood sugar and have been assessed as safe by the authorities, according to Mattilsynet (the Norwegian Food Safety Authority) and Diabetesforbundet (the Norwegian Diabetes Association). Sugar alcohols, which are used in most “sugar-free” sweets, affect blood sugar about half as much as sugar and can cause stomach discomfort. That is the short picture. The details follow.
Sugars: white sugar, honey and syrup
Helsedirektoratet (the Norwegian Directorate of Health) recommends that added and free sugar should be below 10 per cent of energy, and preferably lower. Free sugar covers both sugar added during production and naturally occurring sugar in honey, syrup, fruit juice and juice concentrate. Honey and syrup therefore count the same as granulated sugar in the dietary advice. NHI (Norwegian Health Informatics) writes that granulated sugar (sucrose) is split in the gut into glucose and fructose, and that the rise in blood sugar from sucrose is less than or equal to that from ordinary bread, potatoes and rice. The point is not that sugar is particularly dangerous per gram, but that it gives a lot of carbohydrate without nutrition, in small portions that you easily eat a lot of.
| Sweetener | Sugars per 100 g | Portion | Sugars per portion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar, white | 100 g | 1 tsp (5 g) | 5.0 g |
| Sugar, brown | 94 g | 1 tbsp (10 g) | 9.4 g |
| Honey | 79 g | 1 tsp (11 g) | 8.7 g |
| Syrup | 74 g | 1 tbsp (16 g) | 11.9 g |
| Agave syrup | 70 g | 1 tbsp (16 g) | 11.2 g |
| Soft drink with sugar | 10.6 g | 1 glass (200 g) | 21 g |
| Apple juice | 10.2 g | 1 glass (200 g) | 20 g |
Source: Matvaretabellen (the Norwegian Food Composition Table, Mattilsynet, 2026).
A teaspoon of honey gives more sugar than a teaspoon of sugar, because honey is heavier. Brown sugar, maple syrup and agave syrup are often marketed as healthier. For blood sugar, they are sugar.
Fructose
Fructose (fruit sugar) is sold as a sugar substitute because it gives a smaller rise in blood sugar than ordinary sugar. Diabetesforbundet writes that fructose contains as many calories as sugar, that an intake above 30 grams a day can raise blood fats (triglycerides), and that they instead recommend sweeteners such as stevia or Sukrin.
“No added sugar”, “sugar-free” and “low sugar”
Mattilsynet regulates these claims in its guide on nutrition claims:
- Sugar-free: a maximum of 0.5 grams of sugars per 100 grams or 100 ml.
- Low sugar: a maximum of 5 grams of sugars per 100 grams for solid food, a maximum of 2.5 grams per 100 ml for drinks.
- No added sugar: no sugars or other ingredients with sweetening properties have been added to the product. If the product contains natural sugar, it must be accompanied by the statement “contains naturally occurring sugars”.
The last one is the most important for you. A juice “with no added sugar” can contain 10 grams of sugar per 100 ml from the fruit. According to Matvaretabellen (Mattilsynet, 2026), apple purée without added sugar gives 8.8 grams of carbohydrate per 100 grams, compared with 44 grams in ordinary apple purée, and jam without added sugar 3.5 grams compared with 42 grams. The products are better, but not carbohydrate-free. Diabetesforbundet advises looking at the total carbohydrate content, not just the line “of which sugars”, and reading the ingredient list. “Sugar-free” sweets can also contain flour and starch that raise blood sugar.
Sweeteners: two main groups
Mattilsynet divides sweeteners into two groups. All must be approved in the EU before they can be used, and products containing them must be labelled “contains sweeteners”.
Intense sweeteners
Aspartame (E951), sucralose (E955), acesulfame K (E950), saccharin (E954), cyclamate (E952) and steviol glycosides from stevia (E960). Mattilsynet writes that they are 30 to 3,000 times sweeter than sugar and are used in such small amounts that they give the product no appreciable energy. Diabetesforbundet writes that these provide no calories and do not affect blood sugar. Products with aspartame must also be labelled “contains a source of phenylalanine”, which applies to people with the condition PKU.
On safety, Diabetesforbundet writes that all sweeteners in our food have been thoroughly tested and approved by EFSA, and that a WHO report which questioned long-term effects nevertheless concluded that the benefits of sweeteners outweigh any drawbacks for people with diabetes. Mattilsynet’s risk assessment of aspartame, acesulfame K and sucralose from drinks concludes that intake is below the acceptable daily intake (ADI) for both two-year-olds and adults, and is therefore not a cause for concern. Helsedirektoratet writes that children under three should not have products with sweeteners. Helsenorge (the public health portal, Poison Information Centre) writes that a large intake can cause temporary discomfort in the stomach and gut. We take no position on health effects beyond what the sources say: approved, safe in normal amounts, no rise in blood sugar.
Sugar alcohols
Sorbitol (E420), mannitol (E421), xylitol (E967) and erythritol (E968) are the examples Mattilsynet mentions; maltitol and isomalt belong to the same group. You recognise them by the -ol in the name, and they are the most common in “sugar-free” chocolate, sweets, chewing gum and pastilles. This is what the sources say:
- Mattilsynet: give about the same energy as sugar, except erythritol which gives less. A large intake can have a laxative effect. Products with more than 10 per cent sugar alcohols must be labelled as possibly having a laxative effect. Sorbitol, mannitol and xylitol are not permitted in drinks.
- Diabetesforbundet: sugar alcohols give 2.5 to 4 kcal per gram and affect blood sugar about half as much as ordinary sugar. They should be included when counting carbohydrates. A large intake can cause wind, stomach pain and loose stools. Erythritol (Sukrin) stands out: it does not raise blood sugar, has almost no calories, and in normal use has no laxative effect.
- NHI: sugar-free chocolate sweetened with sugar alcohols raises blood sugar almost as much as ordinary chocolate, has just as much fat and calories, and is more expensive. Nutritionally there is no advantage.
Diabetesforbundet writes that sugar-free pastilles and chewing gum rarely matter for blood sugar, because you use so little at a time. A whole bag of sugar-free sweets is another matter.
Practical: what you can do
- For coffee, tea and yoghurt: intense sweeteners or erythritol give sweetness without a rise in blood sugar according to Diabetesforbundet. Or gradually wean yourself off sweet things.
- For baking: Diabetesforbundet states that Sukrin has the same volume as sugar and can be used for baking. The flour in the cake still gives carbohydrates.
- For drinks: Helsedirektoratet’s advice is water on an everyday basis. Diet soft drinks give 0 grams of carbohydrate according to Matvaretabellen, compared with 21 grams in a glass of soft drink with sugar.
- For “sugar-free” sweets: read the ingredient list. Sugar alcohols count half as much as sugar, flour and starch count in full. Keep the portion small.
- For honey and syrup: use them as sugar, in small amounts that you count, for example in the carb calculator.
Check your own reaction
People react differently, including to sugar alcohols. Measure your blood sugar before and two hours after a portion of “sugar-free” chocolate, and compare with the same amount of dark chocolate. If sugar-free products give you stomach discomfort, it is the sugar alcohols. Talk to your GP (fastlege) if you are unsure how much room sweet things can take in your diet. You will find more on chocolate and sweets in practice in can I eat chocolate and sweets with type 2 diabetes.
Recipes that fit
- Tyttebær, ukokte · Erken-arkivetLingonberries preserved in water without sugar, a tart accompaniment to meat and porridge instead of jam.
- Tropisk melonsalat med mynte · Kulinarisk.noDessert of melon, avocado, cucumber and lime without added sugar, honey or syrup.
- Peanøttsmør fra bunnen av · Kulinarisk.noNut butter without added sugar, unlike many shop-bought varieties.
- Ristede mandler · Erken-arkivetAlmonds roasted without sugar or salt, sweet enough in themselves as a topping on yoghurt.
Frequently asked questions
Is honey better than sugar with diabetes?
No, not for blood sugar. According to Matvaretabellen, a teaspoon of honey (11 g) gives 8.7 grams of sugars, compared with 5 grams in a teaspoon of sugar. Helsedirektoratet counts honey and syrup as free sugar, in the same category as added sugar.
What does "no added sugar" on the packet mean?
According to Mattilsynet's guide, it means that no sugar or other sweetening ingredients have been added to the product, but it may contain natural sugar from fruit or milk. "Sugar-free" means a maximum of 0.5 grams of sugars per 100 grams. Always look at the total carbohydrate content.
Are sweeteners such as aspartame and sucralose safe with diabetes?
Mattilsynet and Diabetesforbundet write that the sweeteners used in Norway have been assessed and approved as safe in normal amounts. Diabetesforbundet writes that intense sweeteners such as aspartame, sucralose and stevia provide no calories and do not affect blood sugar.
Do sugar alcohols affect blood sugar?
Yes, most of them. Diabetesforbundet writes that sugar alcohols such as maltitol, sorbitol and xylitol affect blood sugar about half as much as sugar and give 2.5 to 4 kcal per gram. Erythritol (Sukrin) is the exception and does not raise blood sugar.
Can I drink diet soft drinks with type 2 diabetes?
Diet soft drinks give zero carbohydrate according to Matvaretabellen and do not affect blood sugar. Diabetesforbundet writes that the benefits of sweeteners outweigh the drawbacks for people with diabetes. Helsedirektoratet's advice for everyone is to drink water on an everyday basis.
Sources
- Tilsatt sukker (Utviklingen i norsk kosthold 2024) · Helsedirektoratet
- Godteri, snacks og søte bakevarer bør begrenses · Helsedirektoratet
- Sukker og diabetes · NHI.no
- Er sukkerfri sjokolade et godt alternativ? · NHI.no
- Søtstoffer · Mattilsynet
- Risikovurdering av søtstoffene aspartam, acesulfam K og sukralose fra drikkevarer · Mattilsynet
- Veileder om ernæringspåstander · Mattilsynet
- Søtningsstoffer · Diabetesforbundet
- Søtningsmidler, venn eller fiende? · Diabetesforbundet
- Spørsmål og svar: Søtningsstoffet Sukrin · Diabetesforbundet
- Spørsmål og svar: Fruktose som sukkererstatning? · Diabetesforbundet
- Søtningsstoffer (Giftinformasjonen) · Helsenorge
- Matvaretabellen · Matvaretabellen (Mattilsynet)
Caveat. The content on this page is general information and not medical advice. It does not replace examination, diagnosis or treatment by a doctor. Changes to diet, physical activity, weight or medication should always be made together with your GP or other health professional. Do not change or stop medication on your own. Contact your GP or the out-of-hours clinic (116 117) if you are worried, and call 113 in an emergency. Read the full disclaimer.